Here's how it works: I post an outfit, someone follows up with their opinion, then posts a photo they found :)

I'll start with Linsday:



and I'm going with 'miss' on this one because the layering is just too messy...

Post Last Updated:13.09.2007 at 23.35

No go.. its a miss from me..

Miss, it's too busy. Though she looks a lot hotter as a blonde.

Right, on to the next one - Alessandra Ambrosio (click for the larger images):

Hit, olive is a great colour for her. It looks gorgeous against her bronzed skin.

Hilary Duff

Miss (but i like the tee in the background!)
Hit
Hit...with scraggly looking hair

miss... but it "could" have been cold that day

Given the discussion around the Olsens, here is one:



Hit or miss?

hit
probably the most decent thing ive seen either of those olsens in.
personally i love the all black look, broken up with a bit of silver

Hit, that outfit is awesome.

Hit - again I usually hate what they wear but this one is quite classy for them