Does Sarah Jessica Parker’s face make you pick up a magazine? How many people will whip out their credit card at the mere sight of Lady Gaga?

Box Office power is one thing, but these days its also an annual tradition to look at who was the greatest power of celebrity – as measured by magazine sales.

True, the correlation of cover star to issues sold isn’t exactly scientific. Maybe you bought the February issue of Vanity Fair for its Kennedy retrospective and not because Justin Bieber was on the cover (we’d like to think so). As well as the appeal of the inside content, there’s also the quality of the cover. A great star can be made to look terrible; a cover can be cluttered and unappealing. An issue might also have a special offer or free product attached that helps make up the consumer’s mind.

But all that aside, if you track a particular star across multiple covers, across multiple months, you’re still bound to draw some interesting conclusions.

lady gaga vogue march 2011

WWD reports that in 2011 Lady Gaga wasn’t the unwavering darling of the newsstands that she was in 2010. The report puts the low points down to the fact that Gaga wasn’t photographed as – well – Gaga. Makeup-free and almost unrecognisably natural on the October issue of Harper’s Bazaar, Lady Gaga brought the magazine’s third lowest sales of the year. When Gaga’d up, however, her issues sold just fine. Her March 2011 cover for Vogue (above) was the magazine’s second best seller of the year.

Other consistent successes were Sarah Jessica Parker, Jennifer Aniston, and Heidi Klum – while Mila Kunis was the surprise newcomer to the top sellers list.

So who were the year’s celebrity failures?

mila kunis GQ august 2011

Reese Witherspoon, Michelle Williams, Fergie, Justin Timberlake and Justin Bieber all provoked below average sales when they graced 2011’s magazine covers.

So now the interesting question is, what is it about particular covers, and about particular celebrities, that makes them sell? What magazines, if any, did you buy this year and why?

Share some style:

Want to keep up with fashion?

Once a week, we send out an update with the latest fashion trends, styles and collections.
Get yours direct in your inbox and keep ahead of fashion.

Our newsletter is spam free and your email address will never be shared or sold.

Written by .

Some people's wardrobes are about a small selection of pieces that all fit within one aesthetic - Tania Braukamper isn't such a person. With a wardrobe that spans three different rooms, her approach to fashion is a mixture of current-season key pieces mixed with vintage finds she's sourced on innumerous shopping trips around the world's more cultured capitals. Despite a disparate approach to shopping, Tania is adamant that the key to mixing vintage with new season is to stick to key looks and colours that work for oneself. And it's a theory that she works into her writing for, where she serves as the publication's Editor.